The Postseason Debrief: Fifteen Minutes With Every Runner
Every winter decision depends on things you can’t read off a results sheet. Episode 2 walks through the fifteen-minute debrief: three calls, ten questions, what stays out of the room, and what to do with the answers.
The short version. Hold a fifteen-minute meeting with every runner between day three and day seven after their last race. Ask ten questions in four groups: the season, injuries, the life around running, and what they want. Questions about eating and periods go home to families in a letter. The answers set three calls: how long the break lasts, which path and level the runner starts on, and who sees a doctor first.
The Postseason Debrief: Fifteen Minutes With Every Runner
Cold Open
Ellie was one of the best cross country runners in the state as a junior. She was on the all-state team. She wanted to run in college, and she wanted college coaches to notice her.
By the championship season, she was running on empty, a little less energy every day. The joy had gone out of it, but she gritted it out. She finished the season anyway, because that’s what good runners do.
Now, as a junior thinking about running in college, she felt that she should train all winter, because that’s the rule everybody knows. I didn’t think Ellie needed to. I thought she needed a break from running.
She ended up playing basketball. She wasn’t a great basketball player, but she had fun. The court gave her jumps and speed and agility that running in a straight line never does, and it gave her a few months away from the sport that had worn her down.
She ended up starting for the basketball team. She had a great outdoor season that finished with two races at New Englands. And now she runs for a Division II college team.
Ellie was easy to read. Most athletes are not. And most of them won’t tell you unless you ask.
That’s what this episode is about.
Intro
Welcome to Salty Talks. I’m Coach Saltmarsh, 25 years coaching, 31 state champions.
Last episode was the first six weeks of winter: the break, the easy week, the three-week hold. And every piece of that plan had a blank in it. How long does this kid rest? Which level does she start on? Does she race indoors or train straight through? And is anything going on with her body that needs a doctor before she runs another step?
None of that is on the results sheet. You get it by asking.
So today, the post-season debrief. Fifteen minutes with every runner. The three calls it has to make, ten questions in four groups, what stays out of the room, and what you do with the answers. Then five things for Monday. Let’s go.
Segment One · Three Calls
The debrief is not a goodbye speech. It’s not a goal-setting session either. It’s 15 minutes of collecting what every winter decision depends on. So build it backward from the decisions. There are three.
One, the break. Seven to ten days with no running for a kid who finished a full season, about a week and a half for a partial season, none for a kid who didn’t run cross country. And for a kid who ended hurt, the doctor decides, not you.
Two, the path and the level. Path A races indoors and peaks in February. Path B trains straight through to the beginning of the outdoor season. The level comes from cross country peak week and then gets adjusted for injury.
Three, the health flags. Bone pain, missed periods, not enough eating, not enough sleeping. Some of these mean a call home, and some mean a doctor before winter training starts.
Every question in the meeting feeds one of those three calls. If a question doesn’t change a decision, it’s not in the meeting.
Now, when should you do this? Ideally during the break, between day three and day seven after the athlete’s last race. Not the Monday after, when the race is still raw. And not in January, when the decisions have already been made by default. And it’s her last race, not the team’s. The kid who went to New Englands, or went on to NXR or Foot Locker, gets their debrief the week after that.
Fifteen minutes each. A table in the library or an open-door classroom, phones away. A roster of 30 should take about four afternoons. And that sounds like a lot until you compare it to a winter of guessing.
Do your homework before she sits down. Her cross country peak week in miles: that sets her starting level before she says a word. Her injury record: anything the athletic trainer saw, any days missed, any races she didn’t finish. And then take a look at her last three races against her season’s best.
One more thing goes out before the meetings start. The break letter, to every family, the week the season ends. Hold that thought. It matters in segment three.
Segment Two · Ten Questions
Ten questions, four groups: the season, injuries, life around running, and what do they want.
The season. Question one: tell me about your season in two sentences. That’s it. Two sentences to sum up your season. Two sentences forces a choice. Listen for whether she owns the story or maybe blames it on the weather or teammates. And then compare her version to yours. If her read of her season is far from what you saw as the coach, that’s the first thing to coach this winter.
Question two: when did you feel your best this season? And was there ever a time that running stopped being fun? Listen for a date. “The second week of October” is an answer that you can use. And watch for the kid who ran a season best at the championship and tells you the fun ended weeks before that. That’s Ellie. That was my example. A kid who’s still agreeable, still shows up, but gone by February if nobody notices. That runner gets a full ten days off, and think hard before you put them on an indoor track.
Injuries, two questions. Slow it down here. These are the two that keep kids healthy in February.
Question three: what hurts right now? Show me where. Make them point. One finger on one spot, a foot, a hip, a shin, is different than just saying “my leg hurts.”
Question four: did anything hurt this fall that you didn’t tell me about? This one finds the kid who hid a sore shin to keep a varsity spot.
Then ask about their life around running. Two questions. Distance runners break down on the recovery side first, and most recovery happens in the hours you never see them.
So question five: walk me through a school day. What time do you go to bed? What time do you get up in the morning? You can do the math in front of them. Matt Milewski and his colleagues surveyed 112 middle and high school athletes. The ones who averaged less than eight hours a night were 1.7 times more likely to have been injured. That’s in episode 13, if you missed it.
Listen for the heavy weeks too: exams, job interviews, college applications. Mark them down on your calendar. The heavier weeks get less volume, but the same number of runs.
Then question six: are you playing anything else this winter? If the answer is basketball, skiing, swimming, that’s good news. Remember the Stanford study from the last episode: 748 high school runners. Boys who had played basketball had a lower stress fracture risk.
Ellie’s basketball season wasn’t time off from the plan. It was the plan.
Then what they want. Four questions, and ask these last. By now you know what her body and her calendar will allow, so you can hear her goals against what’s real.
Question seven: do you want to run this winter? Not should. Want. Some say yes before you finish that question. Some shrug. A shrug is an honest answer, and a useful one. The kid that trains on Path B with no pressure to race indoors is the same kid who doesn’t want to quit in March.
Question eight: what do you want the spring to look like? Give me a race and a time. Then walk it back. What has to be true in April for that to happen? What about February? The kid who names a big goal and can’t answer the February question just told you what kind of coaching she needs this winter.
And have your own number ready. Her championship 5K already tells you a realistic spring range for the 1600 and the 3200. There’s a free calculator on the site that does it in seconds.
Question nine: do you want to race indoors? Why? The why matters more than the yes. Chasing a time is a good reason. Racing with friends is a good reason. “My parents want me to” is worth a conversation with the family.
Then check the answer against the rules. First-year runners stay off the indoor track. So does anyone with a bone stress injury this calendar year. So does anyone who finished the fall wrung out, however much they say they want it.
And then question ten, a very important question: is there anything else I should know? And then stop talking. Leave room for some silence.
One caution. Don’t promise to keep everything between the two of you. If what he or she tells you involves safety, you’ll have to act on it. They deserve to know that before they tell you what they want to say.
Segment Three · What Stays Out of the Room
You’ll notice there’s no question about food on that list, or periods, or weight. And that’s on purpose. Those questions don’t belong in a 15-minute meeting across a table from a coach. Those questions belong in writing, to the family that sees that child every day.
I’ll be honest with you about why this matters to me. I am a male coach. Me asking a 16-year-old about her period is not a conversation that goes well for anybody. But it isn’t only a male coach problem. The kid who is restricting or hiding things isn’t going to tell the person who picks the varsity seven.
Whatever you ask in that room, you’re going to get the answer that she thinks will keep her on the team.
It’s also where the medical advice points. The American Academy of Pediatrics wrote its guide to under-fueling for parents, and it isn’t only a girls’ problem. The International Olympic Committee now calls it REDs, relative energy deficiency in sport, and it covers boys too. There’s a whole episode on it from last season. I think it was episode seven.
So the break letter goes home the week after the season ends, with a short paragraph on winter health and two contacts: the pediatrician and the athletic trainer.
That doesn’t mean you stop paying attention. You don’t have to ask about food to notice a kid who isn’t eating enough. Workouts start slipping for no reason. There’s slow recovery, getting sick more often, repeated injuries, low motivation. Boys show fewer outward signs than girls, so watch them just as closely.
If a kid brings it up on her own, listen. Don’t probe. Don’t give advice. Walk her to the athletic trainer that same day.
And one rule for the whole winter: don’t comment on size, shape or weight. Not even as a compliment. Especially not as a compliment.
Segment Four · From Answers to Calls
From answers to the calls you need to make as a coach. You’ve got the ten answers, and here’s how to turn them into calls that matter.
Let’s talk about the break first. The default doesn’t change: seven to ten days, no running, then one easy week. The debrief helps you decide where in that range each athlete lands. Full season, healthy, still enjoying it: seven days. Raced to the last meet, season’s best, but kind of wrung out, or maybe the fun ended in October: ten days, and stretch the easy week. If they’re short on sleep, if they’ve been sick a lot, if they’re eating less: ten days, and fix the sleep and the food before structured training begins.
Longer also doesn’t mean weeks on the couch. When a kid needs more time, give it as more easy, unstructured running, moving on most days. Still no Garmin. Still no workouts. And if an athlete asks you to skip the break, just say no. Those are the miles that turn into a February injury.
Then decide on the path and the level. The team path is a program decision, and you probably made it already. An indoor season that counts, with a championship at the end, would be Path A. Everybody else, Path B. The first-year runner, the kid with a bone stress injury earlier in the year, the kid who felt wrung out at the championship, or the one who says she’s exhausted: those are Path B candidates.
Level comes from peak week. A kid hurt this fall goes one level lower. A kid between two levels goes to the lower one. And the fast kid with low mileage gets set by the mileage, not the speed.
And here’s the good news. The close calls can wait. Weeks one through six are the same on both paths, and nobody races before week seven. If you’re not sure, you’ve got a month of watching them train before you have to commit to anything.
Then the doctor. You’re not diagnosing anything. Your job is to notice, write it down, tell the parents, and then refer them to a resource that can help.
Some flags mean a physician before winter training starts. For example, pain on one spot of the bone, or pain that gets sharper while running. Pain that hasn’t settled in two weeks. A bone stress injury this year with no sign-off for winter running. More than three months between periods. And any sign of weight control: skipping meals on purpose, diet pills, vomiting, extra training to lose weight.
The rest are softer. Short sleep, low energy, eating less, getting sick a lot, a flat mood. One of those on its own, you can watch closely for a week or two. But if you’ve got several of these things and they’re all happening together, that’s a call home, because these flags stack. Michelle Barrack and her colleagues followed 259 active girls and young women. With one risk factor, roughly 15 to 20 percent of them got a bone stress injury. With several together, it climbed to 30 to 50 percent.
And when you call home, call. Don’t email. Say what you saw and heard, not what you think it might be. Something like this:
“He’s been sick twice this month, and he told me he sleeps about six hours a night. His last two workouts were well off his usual. I’m not a doctor, I’m just a coach, but if I were you, I would consider maybe sending him to his pediatrician before winter training starts. I know we both want him to be healthy and happy.”
That’s the whole call. Then let the medical people take it from there.
Segment Five · Monday Morning
Five things you can do this week.
One. If the break letter hasn’t gone home, send it today. Eating, periods and energy live in that letter, not in your meeting. The one I use is free at coachsaltmarsh.com/breakletter.
Two. Build the roster sheet before the first meeting. One line per athlete: peak week, injury record, last three races against the season’s best. Then five empty columns: break end, level, path, flags, follow-up.
Three. Book the meetings. Fifteen minutes each, day three to seven after each kid’s last race. Door open, phones away. If that window already closed for your team, do them this week anyway. Not in January.
Four. Ask the ten questions: the season, the injuries, the life around running, what they want. Fill in the five columns as they give you the answers.
And five. Close the loop. Every athlete with a hard flag, or two soft ones, gets a call home within the week. And every athlete hears where she starts: her level, her path, and the date of her first run.
A decision the athlete never hears is not a decision.
Close
Back to Ellie. By the rules, she trains all winter. A junior with college plans: that’s what juniors with college plans do. She was already headed for burnout. A winter of miles would have finished that job.
Ellie was easy to read. I’d watched her run on empty through the whole championship season, just barely keeping it together. Most kids aren’t that easy. Most of them won’t tell you unless you ask.
That’s the debrief. Fifteen minutes, ten questions, three calls that need to be made by the coach.
Everything I covered today is free in the post-season debrief article on my site, with the tables for the break and the level. If you want the 20 weeks that come after the debrief, both paths, all four levels, every day written out, that’s the Winter Training Block at coachsaltmarsh.com/winter. The Winter Kit has the break letter, the cold policy and a March check-in that closes the loop on this meeting.
Next time: picking the indoor event that builds the spring. The 1000, the 1500, the 3000, and how to match a kid to the one that serves their outdoor season best.
I’m Coach Saltmarsh. Ask, then listen. Keep it salty, and I’ll see you in the next one.
The debrief sets the start. The Block writes the rest.
The Winter Training Block: two paths, four levels set by cross country peak week, and every day from the break to the first outdoor practice. The Winter Kit has the break letter, the cold policy and the March check-in that closes the loop on this meeting.
See the Winter Training Block · $59 →Post-Season Debrief Questions Coaches Ask
When should coaches hold the post-season debrief?
Between day three and day seven after each runner’s own last race. Not the Monday after, when the race is still raw, and not in January, when the decisions have already been made by default. A runner who raced at New Englands or a regional meet gets their debrief the week after that race.
What questions should a coach ask at the end of the cross country season?
Ten questions in four groups. The season: tell me about your season in two sentences, and when did you feel your best. Injuries: what hurts right now, and did anything hurt this fall that you didn’t tell me about. The life around running: bedtime and wake time on a school day, and any winter sport. What they want: do you want to run this winter, what should spring look like, do you want to race indoors and why, and is there anything else I should know.
Should a coach ask runners about eating or periods?
Not in a one-on-one meeting. Those questions go home to families in writing, with the pediatrician and the athletic trainer as the contacts. Coaches still watch for signs of under-fueling: workouts slipping for no reason, slow recovery, getting sick more often, repeated injuries and low motivation.
How does the debrief change the length of the break?
The default is seven to ten days with no running, then one easy week. A healthy runner who still enjoys it gets seven days. A runner who finished wrung out, or whose fun ended in October, gets ten days and a longer easy week. A runner who is short on sleep, sick a lot or eating less gets ten days, and the sleep and food get fixed before structured training starts.
Which runners should see a doctor before winter training?
Runners with pain on one spot of a bone, pain that gets sharper while running, pain that hasn’t settled in two weeks, a bone stress injury this year with no sign-off for winter running, more than three months between periods, or any sign of weight control. Two or more softer flags together, such as short sleep, low energy, eating less, getting sick a lot or a flat mood, mean a call home.
Show Notes and Links
- The Post-Season Debrief: Questions to Ask Every Runner Before Winter
- How long should runners take off after cross country
- Winter Training for High School Distance Runners
- What a Cross Country 5K Tells You About Spring Track
- XC to Track Goal Calculator (free)
- 1000m, 1500m or 3000m: Choosing Indoor Events
- The break letter to families (free template)
- The Winter Training Block
- S2E1: The Six Weeks That Decide Your Spring
- Ep. 13: Sleep Is the Cheapest PR
- Ep. 7: Coaching Female Runners: RED-S and What Coaches Miss
Research Cited
- Milewski MD et al. Chronic lack of sleep is associated with increased sports injuries in adolescent athletes. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, 2014.
- Tenforde AS et al. Identifying sex-specific risk factors for stress fractures in adolescent runners. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2013.
- Barrack MT et al. Higher incidence of bone stress injuries with increasing female athlete triad-related risk factors. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2014.
- Mountjoy M et al. 2023 International Olympic Committee’s consensus statement on Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (REDs). British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2023.
- American Academy of Pediatrics. Guide for parents on under-fueling in young athletes. HealthyChildren.org.